In my post on Dwarf Slayers I make the point that casting
Raise Dead on a deceased Slayer would be a Bad Thing™.
seawasp argued that it should be perfectly normal; you've cleansed your honor, attoned for your sin, now you get to enjoy life. I'd like to address that.
The general rule in Western religious teaching is that worshipers of a particular faith will be rewarded with an eternal existence in the afterlife. Whether its Heaven or Valhalla, the teachings are clear: Obey the rules set down in the Holy Texts and follow the teachings of the priests, and when you die, you get to live forever basking in the glory of God (or whatever that religion promises.) Some afterlives aren't eternal. The warriors boozing it up in Valhalla know that when Rangarok comes that are fated to fight and lose to the giants. But until then, they'll battle by day and party all night.
This seems to be the model used by most FRPG cosmologies, especially D&D with its inner and outer planes. You die, and your soul travels to the appropriate Outer Plane for an eternity of pleasure/punishment/F-Troop reruns. Which brings up back to our dead Dwarf Slayer.
( Let's set up a little scenario )Then there are the Death Cults. Not all death religions are going to be evil, I'm thinking specifically of the Humakt cult from
RuneQuest. How are they going to feel about raising the dead? Undead? I can easily see a case where a church worshiping death might have temple assassins that exist solely to kill those who mock death by being raised! Finally, you have the feelings of the dead person. I don't know about the rest of you, but if were to drop dead this minute and find myself in some version of paradise (for me? a library containing every written work every created, and the ability to read them all...) I wouldn't want to come back! Since
Raise Dead is generally an expensive ritual to perform (and costs even more to get a temple to do for you) you better make sure that the person being raised wants to come back! Generally, unless there was some great work left undone, some terrible wrong that needed to be righted, most people are going to opt to stay in the afterlife. Of course, those who were judged and found wanting will probably jump at the chance to get a new start in life...
Just some thoughts on the subject. I'd love to hear what other people's take on this is.